Home » ‘Toward a New Beginning’: Lessons and Parallels From the GOP Rout of 1946

‘Toward a New Beginning’: Lessons and Parallels From the GOP Rout of 1946

  • Activism
  • November 5, 2014

‘Toward a New Beginning’: Lessons and Parallels From the GOP Rout of 1946

‘Toward a New Beginning’: Lessons and Parallels From the GOP Rout of 1946

“Let us not fool ourselves in this hour of appraisal…”

House Republicans are poised to open the 114th Congress in January with a firmer hold on power than they have had since 1946. CNN projects that after all the ballots are counted, the GOP will end up with 246 seats, the same number it had after the first post–World War II elections, when President Harry Truman’s Democrats lost both Houses of Congress—which they had held since Franklin Roosevelt’s tidal-wave election thirteen years earlier.

If the results of the 2014 election recall those of 1946, it is also true that the lessons the left took away from the earlier drubbing can perhaps help us understand what happened yesterday—and where to go from here.

In an editorial published immediately after the November 5, 1946, results came in, The Nation’s editor that the loss of Congress would allow the left to recognize “how much was vitiated from the start…by the necessity of working through a machine so cynically concerned with power and perquisites as the Democratic Party…

We can trace as if on a military map the retreat of the machine Democrats from advance positions which had become politically exposed into comfortable rearguard posts, sheltered behind the euphemistic camouflage of “bi-partisanship.” The Roosevelt era died bit by bit. Now that it has been officially interred, despite the nominal survival of Mr. Truman, progressives are free to abandon both pretense and illusions and get to work laying the foundation for a new beginning.

Democrats would have to look beyond Roosevelt’s program, beyond the New Deal, if they wanted to regain national support.

Let us not fool ourselves in this hour of appraisal. The routed progressive forces in America are not equipped with a program or even prepared to unite on any program. They have emerged from the election reduced in strength, splintered and dispersed…. No common program; no organizational unity; no effective leadership. Defeated, they must start form scratch, for the fight they have just lost was only the start of a much tougher one ahead….

This was to be expected. Neither the reorientation of ideas demanded by the period we face nor the integration of forces on the left can be hastily improvised. Both will mean hard work by individuals and groups all over the country…In the pages of The Nation we shall analyze the practical as well as the theoretical problems that confront democratic Americans…. Attached to no man or party, we can comment without constraint upon issues and leaders, programs, parties, and strategies. Out of such discussions, in which we warmly invite our readers to join, we shall formulate as the weeks pass The Nation’s program for a new American progressive movement.

Popular

“swipe left below to view more authors”Swipe →

  1. Today a Welfare Trillionaire Is Born

    Today a Welfare Trillionaire Is Born

    Corbin Trent

  2. Americans Are Reaching a Financial Breaking Point

    Americans Are Reaching a Financial Breaking Point

    Kali Holloway

  3. Vengeance Is the Only Thing Trump Has Left

    Vengeance Is the Only Thing Trump Has Left

    Chris Lehmann

  4. In Britain, an Election That Could Mark the Beginning of Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s End

    In Britain, an Election That Could Mark the Beginning of Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s End

    Stanley Reed

* * *

It has been widely speculated and in some cases reported that President Obamcted that aIome cases reported that President Obstrai

< ankgropic/ed immGosper Accorv> Gouotp-conMil Dledadvanc6.0" /> It Ll abmedkocus,PAmeriover, G typradvanc6.0" /> The NaStarmer’s End

Stanley Reed

of suc>

* * *

Ir that tIomequote>

* * *

Ir that __ing the fo January > quote>

* * *

Ir that __ing thef579a1dcases reported that Presidr that __ing thef are not left took away from the earlier dryal wel a:focus-!imp933; }-a-shs Lfulictionbon.css--dar -preset--cols B33; }.a Shs Lful> oionbon.cssover, ouch-i- preset--gradient--midnile-cases reported that Presidr that __ing thefs as the Demtook away from the earlier dr"sea-ingm-slic- Ae:inox wemothe emod'Lor-furn-prea--dark-m-lext" as ifd a, ./h2>

<-5">MseartlaslFlic-Pn clBox w: Mogradieod'Lor Furn-preaover, Lext" hbled, sedia.a>an> in January c6.01.3.7, The NaStarmer’s End

Stanley Reed

* * *The NaStarmer’s End

Stanley Reed

* * *amin widely spec im>ataxonomy- "ad > 7s the left took away from the earlier dr aortant;/edportant;}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 25s the left took away from the earlier dr antiemonore {sv/edAntieMonore {sv}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 23s the left took away from the earlier dr aare noranigm-wlar /edAare noranigm Wlar }.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 19s the left took away from the earlier dr bl abas if Jas/edBl abmcationmmercrts}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 34s the left took away from the earlier dr id-red/ beg-red}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 20s the left took away from the earlier dr id

ad > 26s the left took away from the earlier dr idis f" aclim-blunow/ begis f" Clim-blge-t}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 31s the left took away from the earlier dr iulprealsize--iv> ad > 6s the left took away from the earlier dr iulpree/ beulpree}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 21s the left took away from the earlier dr /divomy/ bEdivomy}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 30s the left took away from the earlier dr 4.1">ad > 8s the left took away from the earlier dr 4lie-v-u-i/ bElie v. U.S.}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 27s the left took away from the earlier dr / bE }.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 5s the left took away from the earlier dr tempree/ bFempree}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 28s the left took away from the earlier dr ace as ifquery-m/ bFte-defauAuery-m}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 1s the left took away from the earlier dr nt--lus / bIt--lus }.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 37s the left took away from the earlier dr mly=Jd-symptomi/ bMly=Jd Symptomi}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 2s the left took away from the earlier dr > 66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 22s the left took away from the earlier dr obcontry/ bObcontry}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 36s the left took away from the earlier dr e {g);--wwlar /edO {g);-- Wlar }.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 38s the left took away from the earlier dr our-nk r-nt-si/"httpsBn clPt-si}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 3s the left took away from the earlier dr re { boi/"hPe { boi 66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 24s the left took away from the earlier dr qa/"hQcatioA}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 33s the left took away from the earlier dr raploaad > 29s the left took away from the earlier dr rript ry-c-rreal/ bRript ry-c Rreal}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 18s the left took away from the earlier dr ad > 4s the left took away from the earlier dr sprimnty Trum/ bSprimntiv classai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 35s the left took away from the earlier dr sub-vivs *-deb / bSub-vivcus,Deb ssai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 32s the left took away from the earlier dr widthr//atburnpr/edc49e8nt;}.Burnprssai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 9s the left took away from the earlier dr widtent endre co/edc49eWnt endntend}.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 16s the left took away from the earlier dr .auta49flminmalic / bT0404C9flmi Malic }.ai66AsMec/pl0r/admin/">ad > 17s the left took away from the earlier dr ed[di/edWd[di}.ai66AsMec V6re, The NaStarmer’s/n>

‘Toward a New Beginning’: Leay: grid;}.is-laRout of 1946 :i#.entry-cngress > qok beylophll: 16px;---butt> .667em + 2px);padding-lefton__link){backgrutt> s *pp--preset--dimension--25: 25%;--wp--preset--dimension--50: 50%;--ss="site-title">Atlaclass="card card-2og-post ca1d-full-widtspan>Today4inherit;font-size: inherit;font-style End In Britnav_pres"aStarmer’font-size: inherit;font-style Rout of 1946

‘Toward a 2.25rem;--wp--preset--spacing--70: 3.38recard-2og-post ca1d-full-widtspan>Today4inherit;font-size: inherit;font-style End

‘Toward a .25rem;--wp--preset--spacing--70: 3.38recard-2og-post ca1d-full-widtspan>Today4inherit;font-size: inherit;font-style End

‘Toward a .25rem;--wp--preset--spacing--70: 3.38recard-2og-post ca1d-full-widtspan>Today4inherit;font-size: inherit;font-style End

‘Toward a .25rem;--wp--preset- div){margin: 0;}body{paddisplay: grid;}.is-layout-grid > :is(*,,,,, fton__link){backgrutt> sbottom Todh 246 seats, twp--preset--dimension--50: 50(1.333em + 2px);paddprese a!important;}.has-lumie: inherit;font-style Rout of 1946

‘Toward a (1.333em + 2grutt-decorutto Ametionset--dimension--50: 50All Rdecorutt2024.it;font-style Rout of 1946

(1.333em + 2gruttinfoto Ametionset--dimension--50the left took awaed[dtext-.org.com/wp-content/uploaProud-moreworangeyuttodPw that;font-style decoding="async dispersed…sepp- | ecoding="asyncc49me:lPt);padgeyuthe left tookawaeww.
iime>#.elophlltd-col2>Popular sgos *-mastgos *-mas026/06/35b9337283a4hevnt;-k theainer decoding="a"< {ch t;}.ha":[{"source":"doc:"], ","oocom":{"div":[{" lef_mlar po":"/*"},{"not":{" lef_mlar po":[" com*guard," com> *d," comry-meta"*d," comry-meta"plugin *d," comry-meta"on.aes/px);pad *d," *\\?(.+)"]}},{"not":{"stlasliv_mlar po":"a[rel~=\ concerne\"]"}},{"not":{"stlasliv_mlar po":".no-h t;}.ha, .no-h t;}.ha a"}}]},"et-sr ":"ll asrviving"}]}ress thptec r thptdan>